In this article
After this article, you can
- Identify the segment used as the penetration denominator.
- Check a threshold without mixing the body with the full range.
Terms at hand: Backtesting · Trading plan · Demo account · Stop loss · Short position · Relative Strength Index (RSI)
After several days of gains on EUR/USD, price pushed to a fresh high and the buyers looked unbeatable. First a long green candle, as if the rally would never end. Then a small candle pushed up above its close, in which neither side settled anything. And finally a strong red candle that closed deep inside the body of the first. That is the evening star, one of the clearest warnings of a top in candlestick analysis.
What the evening star is and where the three rivers come from
The evening star is a three-candle pattern that appears at the top of an uptrend and signals a reversal to the downside. The first candle is long and bullish, a continuation of the rally in which demand still wins. The second is the star itself: a small-bodied candle that, in the classic stock-market description, opens on a gap above the close of the first — on the currency market it is enough that its body sits clearly above the body of its predecessor. The third is long and bearish and closes deep, reaching at least the midpoint of the first candle's body.
The name three rivers comes from the Japanese candlestick tradition, in which sequences of three candles were described by the poetic term sankawa, meaning three rivers. Western readers met these patterns through Steve Nison, whose Japanese Candlestick Charting Techniques of 1991 carried the Japanese body of work into English. If you would first like to map out which candlestick patterns are worth knowing first, start with that piece.
The psychology: euphoria, indecision, reversal
The strength of this pattern comes from the clear story it tells in three acts. The first candle is euphoria. Buyers dominate and latecomers jump in for fear the train will leave without them, so the advance looks unstoppable.
The second candle is the calm before the turn. The gap higher shows optimism is still strong, but the small body means demand has lost its momentum while supply has not yet seized the initiative. The third candle resolves the tension, as sellers return decisively, push price down and close deep inside the body of the first. The market has just changed hands.
The evening star is a top reversal pattern: just as the evening star announces the coming of night, this three-candle sequence warns of lower prices (a paraphrase, not a verbatim quote). — Steve Nison, Japanese Candlestick Charting Techniques, second edition, Prentice Hall, 2001.
The mirror image: the morning star
The evening star has its exact opposite at the bottom of a trend, the morning star. The structure is inverted: a long bearish candle, then a small star on a gap lower, and finally a long bullish candle closing inside the body of the first. Where the evening star heralds dusk and losses, the morning star foretells sunrise and gains. I unpack the same logic, in the bullish direction, in the piece on the morning star.
Two variants are worth knowing. When the middle candle is a true doji, with an almost zero body, we have the evening doji star, and the signal is regarded as stronger. The extreme case is the abandoned baby pattern, in which the middle doji is isolated by gaps on both sides. A related warning of a top is the three black crows, three bearish candles with no middle star.
Four units can mean 40% or 10%
First Close 110 to third Close 106 spans 4 units. The first body is 10; the full range 40. Body penetration is 4/10 = 40%; dividing by range gives 4/40 = 10%. Changing the denominator can reject the same Close under our separate 30% example threshold, despite unchanged price.
For our separate 30%-body variant, compare 106 with 110 − 0.30 × 10 = 107: penetration passes. Incorrectly substituting 40 gives threshold 98, which this Close does not cross downward. “30% of the candle” is ambiguous: name the segment and its starting point. This example differs from the article’s midpoint rule. Correct penetration is only one pattern condition and does not forecast the next price.
Assumptions: Invented first candle: O = 100; C = 110; H = 125; L = 85. Last Close 106. We compare only penetration, not a complete Evening Star flag. All values share one arbitrary price unit; no financial result is supplied. Official material: TA-Lib 0.6.4: CDLEVENINGSTAR.
How to trade the evening star step by step
Start with context. The evening star makes sense only at the top of a clear uptrend; without a prior rally the identical sequence means nothing. Then wait for confirmation. The close of the third candle below the middle of the first is necessary, but a cautious trader opens a position only at the open of the next candle, or after a break of the third candle's low.
Your protective stop loss goes above the high of the middle star, the highest point of the pattern, since a move beyond it voids the reversal story. The stop is not optional but a condition of entry: you have to know in advance where you admit you were wrong. Set the target at the nearest meaningful support, and before you click, compare the distance to it with the distance to the stop — if the target sits closer than the protective order, let the setup go. Reliability also rises with a confluence of signals: if an overbought reading confirms the exhaustion of the advance in the same place, the setup is stronger, and I cover the RSI indicator separately.
Consider a hypothetical EUR/USD sequence. The first body is 1.0900–1.0990, midpoint 1.0945. To make the small second body clearly above it, assume Open 1.0992 and Close 1.1000, High 1.1005; this is an explicitly gapped illustrative variant. The third opens 1.0992 and closes 1.0930, below the first-body midpoint. This only checks the stated body placement and penetration. Record the full OHLC and history before evaluating a complete detector, and define a later entry and stop using executable quotes.
The most common mistakes when trading the evening star
The first mistake is trading the pattern in isolation from the trend. Three candles of the right shape inside a consolidation are not an evening star, because there is nothing to reverse. The second is entering without confirmation, reacting to the third candle alone before price has cemented it.
The third mistake concerns the gaps. In the textbooks the evening star has gaps between the candles, but the currency market trades around the clock and genuine gaps are rare, mainly after the weekend. Treat them as a welcome bonus, not a requirement; what matters most is the close of the third candle below the middle of the first. The fourth is a stop set below the high of the star rather than above it, so the first flicker of price knocks you out of a sound position. The fifth is the illusion of precision. Nowhere is it written how many pips a "long" candle must span or how small the body of the star has to be — reading the setup is a judgement call, and two analysts can point at different things on the same chart. The pattern does not replace a plan, and you place the protective order exactly as you would on any other signal. The evening star is a close relative of other reversal candles, such as the engulfing pattern, all sharing the same logic of confirmation.
What to do tomorrow
- Open a daily chart and find three evening stars from the past. Mark each sequence of a long bullish candle, a small star and a strong bearish candle at the top of a clear advance, then check what happened next, to train your eye before risking capital.
- Write down your own definition of confirmation. Set it on paper that the third candle must close below the middle of the first, that you enter only after a break of the pattern's low, and that the stop sits above the high of the middle star, because a clear rule blocks impulsive entries into an unfinished setup.
- Pair the star with a second, independent signal. Check whether the pattern falls on resistance you drew earlier or whether an oscillator shows overbought, and treat the confluence of two clues as a condition for entry, because the candle alone is rarely enough.
- Practise the whole thing on a demo account for at least a week. Catch a few evening stars live, write out the entry, stop and target for each according to your rule, then tally the result, because only repeatability on a demo earns the right to real money.
To place the evening star in a broader context, a good starting point is the technical analysis section in our library.
Check your understanding
One short exercise
About 2 min · you can try again
C1 = 110, C3 = 106, first body 10, full range 40. Which penetration applies to a body-based threshold?
- 10%, because High − Low is always used.
- 40%, because 4/10 = 0.4.
- 4%, because price fell four units.
Check the answer and explanation
40%, because 4/10 = 0.4.
Correct. The four-unit move from C1 spans 40% of the first body.
Frequently asked
What is the evening star pattern?
The evening star is a three-candle reversal pattern that appears at the top of an uptrend and signals a decline. It is formed by three consecutive candles: a long bullish candle that continues the rally, a small middle candle — the star itself, which the classic stock-market description has opening on a gap higher, while on the currency market it is enough that its body sits clearly above the body of its predecessor — and a long bearish candle that closes at least below the middle of the first candle's body. That final close matters most, because only it confirms the initiative has passed from buyers to sellers. The name alludes to the evening star seen just before nightfall, and thus the start of a decline.
How does the evening star differ from the morning star?
They are two mirror patterns that differ in place and direction. The evening star appears at the top of an uptrend and is a bearish signal: it ends with a long red candle, like dusk after the day. The morning star has an identical three-candle structure but forms at the bottom of a downtrend and foretells a rise: it ends with a strong green candle, like sunrise. In both, the middle candle is small and marks indecision, and the third candle must close deep inside the body of the first for the pattern to be confirmed. The same logic, two opposite directions — which is why it pays to know both at once and not confuse their context on the chart.
How do you trade the evening star?
First make sure the pattern appears at the top of a clear uptrend, because without a prior rally there is nothing to reverse. Then wait for confirmation: the third candle must close below the middle of the first, and a cautious trader enters only after a break of the whole pattern's low or at the open of the next candle. Place your protective order above the high of the middle star, the highest point of the setup, because a move beyond it voids the signal. Set the target at the nearest meaningful support and, before you click, compare the distance to it with the distance to the stop — if the target sits closer, let the entry go. Reliability grows on higher timeframes and when another tool, such as an overbought oscillator, confirms the exhaustion of the advance in the same place.
Sources & bibliography
-
Thomas N. Bulkowski Evening Star Candlestick — performance statistics · odsetek odwróceń niedźwiedzich (72%) oraz wysoka pozycja gwiazdy wieczornej (4. miejsce) w rankingu skuteczności ponad stu formacji świecowych thepatternsite.com ↗
-
Thomas N. Bulkowski Evening Doji Star Candlestick — performance statistics · dane dla wariantu z doji w środku formacji, uchodzącego za mocniejszy sygnał odwrócenia na szczycie trendu thepatternsite.com ↗
-
Thomas N. Bulkowski Morning Star Candlestick — performance statistics · statystyki lustrzanej formacji byczej na dnie trendu, potwierdzające symetrię obu układów gwiazdy thepatternsite.com ↗
-
Bank for International Settlements Triennial Central Bank Survey 2022 · skala i całodobowy charakter rynku walutowego, który tłumaczy rzadkość prawdziwych luk między świecami na Forexie www.bis.org ↗
